News

WILLIAMSVILLE, N.Y. -  Mental toughness was the name of the game Wednesday in the final round of the 42nd New York State Golf Association Men’s Mid-Amateur Championship.

Related: Results / Photos / Day 2 Recap / Championship Central

With winds blowing at 20 mph and gusting to 35 mph and greens at the Country Club of Buffalo running lightning fast, it was a war of attrition on every player’s scorecard.

Victor’s Christian Chapman showed he had the true grit to withstand the test, finishing of a wire-to-wire victory and prevailing by three shots in the 25-and-over event.

Chapman, a 27-year-old who plays out of Cobblestone Creek Country Club, followed rounds of 66 and 72 with an 8-over 78 on the final 18. The average score of the 39 players in the field Wednesday was 79.5. Chapman finished at 6-over 216. John Duthie, a 37-year-old who plays out of Cornell University’s Robert Trent Jones Golf Course, placed second at 9-over 219 after shooting the low round of the day, 3-over 73.

Chapman has been knocking on the door of a state title in recent years. He held the 54-hole lead at the New York State Men’s Amateur championship in July before finishing third. He was third at last year’s NYSGA Mid-Amateur. His triumph was no surprise because he took a six-shot lead into the final 18, but the conditions made it supremely hard-earned.

“I don’t even know how to describe it,” Chapman said. “I’ve been really close a couple times. . . . And it was so hard today. I felt the weight of it for sure. Having such a big lead, it's so hard because you want to play conservative, but you can't play too conservatively. And John played unbelievable. I mean, he shot the lowest round of the day. Being in the same group watching it, I felt the footsteps a little bit. So to come out on top, it feels awesome.”

The 5-foot-8, 175-pound Chapman won the NYSGA 2016 Boys 18U title and starred collegiately at St. Bonaventure. He won the 2022 Rochester District title. Then he took a shot as a professional for two years, playing minitour events and in South America on the PGA Tour Americas. As numerous others in the NYS Mid-Am field know, it’s a hard way to make a living.

“I enjoyed it, it was really fun, but at the same time, it's very costly, and I just didn't feel like my game was there,” Chapman said of his pro foray. “It takes a long time to get there. The Collin Morikawas of the world, the guys that go straight from college to pro success, are very rare, and there’s about one or two of them every year.

“Playing with guys on tour and playing the Monday qualifiers, I saw the talent level and figured that I was probably three or four years away or maybe longer,” he said. “My second season, I traveled I think 29 weeks throughout the year, and it just it killed me. It's not fun living at a hotel. I'm a very family-oriented guy. I want to be home. I want to be around my family.”

Now Chapman works as a client services associate at Compass Wealth Management in Pittsford, and he has developed into an elite amateur. He won the Rochester District Mid-Amateur title in August with an eagle on the final hole.

Talk to Chapman a bit, and it’s apparent that he has the self-assuredness needed to succeed as a top amateur. It’s not cockiness, but more a steadfast belief in his game.

“Yeah, I do because I’ve spent so many years doing it, and I’ve had such amazing people along the way helping me along,” Chapman said.

Chapman credits former Cobblestone Creek pro Neil Reidy and current pro Michael Basch with helping him hone his mechanics. He credits former St. Bona coach Ryan Swanson with helping develop his mental game.

“Those three pros really have helped me get where I am,” Chapman said.

Chapman’s unshakable nature was on display early Wednesday after he drove into fairway bunkers on each of the first two holes and made back-to-back double-bogey 6s.

His lead was four shots over Duthie, five over Williamsville’s Jake Katz, when he stepped to the tee of the 290-yard fifth hole, playing into the strong wind. Duthie and Katz took out 3-irons. Chapman pulled out his driver and hit it onto the green, 25 feet away.

“That was the best swing I made all week,” Chapman said. “I in no way thought I was going to get there. If I was 40 yards short, I would have been happy. I was pretty confident in the decision. It’s gutsy at the time because I had just given up a lot of shots quickly so if I made a mistake hitting driver, the six-shot lead is gone in five holes. But again, I’m a confident player. I really, really believe in myself. In that moment I felt I had the ability to hit that shot. I just told myself to commit to it and I did.”

The grind continued. Chapman hit 9-iron and parred CCB’s famed 156-yard, par-3 sixth hole, aka “the Pulpit hole,” with its tilted green rising out of the ground like a volcano, surrounded by a former limestone quarry. That hole played to the highest stroke average on the day (4.03), with 13 players making double bogey or worse.

The par-3 eighth played 252 yards into a howling wind, with 28 of 39 players making bogey or worse. The 551-yard 13^thplayed downwind. Chapman hit his drive 325 yet made bogey; Duthie hit a 356-yard drive and made par. That cut Chapman’s lead to three.

On the par-4 15^th, Chapman sank a gutsy 7-footer for par to Duthie’s bogey and allowed himself a small fist-pump, his first show of emotion on the day. On the 197-yard 16^th into the gale, Duthie’s knockdown iron landed on the green, 25 feet short, but the wind blew it down the false front, 25 yards into the fairway. Unlucky. Chapman played a brilliant shot from the left bunker, aiming 25 feet away from the pin, to the back of the green, and he let the ball roll down to 6 feet. He made the putt for a great par.

“I basically played the bunker shot to the back edge, and it had enough check and spin with the wind and gravity to come all the way to the pin,” Chapman said. “I would say that was the second best shot of my day.”

After a routine par on 18, Chapman hugged his dad, Rob.

Duthie, who won the 2007 NYS Amateur as an 18-year-old, had a 10-year pro career that included time on the Canadian Tour. After regaining his amateur status in 2024, he placed fourth at both the NYS Amateur and the NYS Mid-Amateur.

“It was just survival out there,” Duthie said. “It was so hard, you just had to think about lagging every putt and try to find a way to make par – or bogey.”

Placing third was 40-year-old Billy Hanes of East Aurora’s Crag Burn Golf Club. Hanes, the NYSGA Mid-Am champion in 2022 and 2023, tied for the second-lowest round of the day (74) and finished 13-over.

“It felt more like a 68,” said Hanes of his 74. “I played well but it was super hard. I felt like I had a real advantage out here compared to most guys who don’t know this place as well as I do. I’m pretty disappointed with how I played overall, to be honest, because of my advantage here. I felt like I had a good chance to win here this week. But I was happy to fight through it.” 

Jack Maguire, 26, of Whippoorwill Golf Club and a former Colgate golfer, was fourth at 14 over.

“I felt like I was putting pretty well but it didn’t show because I wasn’t making many,” Maguire said. “You had to die it to the hole or else you were going to three putt.”

Michael Donner, 26, of Crag Burn, was fifth at 15 over.

CCB will serve as host for the U.S. Women’s Mid-Amateur Championship in September 2027.